Showing posts with label INTERRELIGIOUS DIALOGUE ACCORDING TO MICHAEL AMALADOSS. Show all posts
Showing posts with label INTERRELIGIOUS DIALOGUE ACCORDING TO MICHAEL AMALADOSS. Show all posts

INTERRELIGIOUS DIALOGUE ACCORDING TO MICHAEL AMALADOSS (A POSSIBLE WAY OF DOING THEOLOGY IN ASIA )

1.Introduction

Michael Amaladoss eloquently defines dialogue as a conversation where people seek to enter into a relationship with others in spite of their differences. This dialogue is based on mutual respect, understanding, trust and acceptance of the other believers.[1] The other here refers to one who differs from another or whom one considers to be different from him/her in terms of religion, ethnic group or ideology. It is the ‘other’ that one engages in dialogue with, listening and learning from him/her of an undetermined end, a long process and unfathomable result. For that reason, Dialogue needs incredible patience, openness, trust, determination, courage and prayer.


Why, then, does Interreligious Dialogue become one of the most significant elements in doing Theology in Asia ? The most and foremost reason is that Asia is the birthplace of the great world religions such as Islam, Hinduism, Buddhism, Shintoism, Sikhism, Jainism, Judaism and Christianity.[2] These religions have certainly formed the lives and cultures of Asian peoples and they continuously give a significant meaning to their lives. All these religions believe in a compassionate God who incarnated in Buddha, Siva, Krishna , Muhammad or Jesus, has shown that God cares for the weak. Needless to say that Asia is also a place of the reappearance of religious fundamentalism and new religious movements.


The other reason also why Interreligious Dialogue should be considered such an important aspect in doing Theology in Asia is because Asia is known as a continent of teeming masses of young people. Its lands are home to about two-thirds of the world’s population. Asia carries a face marked with poverty, ill health, under nourishment and suffering caused by war.[3] Simultaneously, the high waves of urbanization, worker exploitation, financial mismanagement, family disintegration, environmental pollution, and trans-national migration[4] are direct impacts on the condition of life of the poor which have threatened their survival.


This essay, therefore, will focus on the notion of Interreligious Dialogue according to Michael Amaladoss. For this aim, I would like to present his background, the meaning, and the three faces of Interreligious Dialogue in his point of view. This present essay, then, will explore the forms of Interreligious Dialogue and three obstacles in doing Interreligious Dialogue in the Asian context. After exploring his insights, the author will come to draw the theological reflection to emphasize what is necessary to do in the future in terms of the continuation of doing Theology in the Asian context before summing up the final thought.

2. Michael Amaladoss’ Background; A call to dialogue
4. Meaning, goals and Three Faces of Interreligious Dialogue
4.1. Meaning
4.2. Goals
4.3. Three Faces of Interreligious Dialogue
4.3.1. Dialogue and Liberation
4.3.2. Dialogue and Cultures
4.3.3. Dialogue: as an Interreligious Encounter
5. Forms of Interreligious Dialogue
6. Obstacles to Dialogue

7. Theological Reflection and Conclusion

Michael Amaladoss has underlined the “key points” of Interreligious Dialogue in doing Theology in Asia . Interreligious Dialogue is a meeting and communication between persons about a deeper grasp of the truth and to achieve a better human relationship in a spirit of sincerity, respect and mutual trust of the other religions. It is a way in which people (believers) come to appreciate each other even in the face of their differences. Interreligious Dialogue, therefore, should provide a ground where people can express their feelings freely and seek ways of resolving long-standing differences.

Amaladoss, then, has described the forms of Interreligious Dialogue, in which the practical aspect of dialogue will come to “ground”. Dialogue, however, should not be done only on the intellectual or spiritual level, detached from the social misery and the physical sufferings of so many people; it should be carried out in those very situations. In doing so, I believe, it will help people to know each other’s faith more deeply, the things they have in common and those that differ. Above all, I believe that the great continent of Asia would not only be known as the great birthplace of massive religions but also as the home where seeds of peace would be deeply rooted in the hearts and lives of people.


Bibliography


Bibliography

<< Back to article

Books:

Amaladoss, Michael, Making All Things New, Dialogue, Pluralism & Evangelization in Asia . New York : Orbis Books, 1990.

…….,,,, Making Harmony, Living in a Pluralist World, Delhi : IDCR & ISPCK,

2003.
………., Walking Together; the Practice of Inter-religious Dialogue. Gujarat: Gujarat Sahitya Prakash, 1992.

Bishops’ Institute for Inter-Religious Affair (BIRA I), “Statement and Recommendations of the first Bishops’ Institute for Inter-Religious Affair. Bangkok , Thailand 18 October 1979, For All the People of Asia : Federation of Asian Bishops’ Conferences Documents from 1970-1991, vol.1, ed. Rosales, G.B. and C.G. Arevalo, Quenzon city: Philippines . Claretian Publications, 1992.

Websites:

Chia, Edmund. Dialogue with Religious of Asia : Challenges from without.

retrieved via internet, 15 August 2008, www.sedos.org/english/without_chia.html

Amaladoss, Michael. Jesuit in Inter-Religious Dialogue in India, retrieved via

Internet, 21st August 2008, www.con-spiration.de/texte/english/2006/dialog-e.html -34k, 57-67.

……… Double Religious Belonging and Liminality an Antropho-Theological

Reflection, retrieved via Internet, 2nd October 2008,

http://www.sedos.org/english/amaladoss_8.htm

……… Dialogue as Conflict Resolution, retrieved via Internet, 1st October 2008

http://www.sedos.org/english/amaladoss1.html

[1]Michael Amaladoss, Walking Together; the practice of Inter-Religious Dialogue, (Gujarat: Gujarat Sahitya Prakash, 1992), 3.

[2]Edmund Chia, Dialogue with Religious of Asia : Challenges from without, (retrieved via internet, 15 August 2008, www.sedos.org/english/without_chia.html), 2.

[3] Federation of Asian Bishop’ conference (FABC), “Asian Bishops’ meeting: message and resolutions of the Asian Bishops’ meeting. Manila, Philippines, 29 November 1970, “ For all the people of Asia : Federation of Asian Bishops’ conferences Documents from 1970-1991, vol 1, ed. Rosales, G. B. and C.G. Arevalo (quezon city, Philippines, Claretian publication, 1992), 4, n 5.

[4] Edmund Chia, Dialogue with Religious of Asia : Challenges from without, (retrieved via internet, 15 August 2008, www.sedos.org/english/without_chia.html), 1

[5] Michael Amaladoss, Walking Together; 3.

[6] Michael Amaladoss, Dialogue as Conflict Resolution, (retrieved via Internet, 1st October 2008, http://www.sedos.org/english/amaladoss1.html), 17.

[7]Ibid., 155.

[8]Ibid.,

[9]Ibid.,3.

[10]Ibid.,

[11]Ibid.,4-6.

[12]Ibid.,

[13] The minutes of meeting a group of Asian bishops in Madras, 1982, quoted from Michael Amaladoss, Walking Together, the practice of Inter-religious Dialogue, (Gujarat: Gujarat Sahitya Prakash, 1992), 4.

[14] Michael Amaladoss, Making Harmony, Living in a Pluralist World ( Delhi : Cambridge Press, 2003), 65.

[15] Ibid.,5.

[16]Ibid.,7.

[17]Ibid.,

[18] Michael Amaladoss, Jesuit in Inter-Religious Dialogue in India, (retrieved via Internet, 21st August 2008, www.con-spiration.de/texte/english/2006/dialog-e.html - 34k, 57-67.

[19] Ibid., 59.

[20] Ibid.,

[21] Ibid.,60.

[22] Ibid.,62.

[23]Michael Amaladoss, Dialogue as Conflict Resolution, (retrieved via Internet, 1st October 2008, http://www.sedos.org/english/amaladoss1.html), 13.

[24] Ibid., 18.

[25] Ibid., 19.

[26] Ibid.,

[27] Ibid., 20.

[28] Michael Amaladoss, Making All Things New, Dialogue, Pluralism & Evangelization in Asia , (New York: Orbis Books, 1990), 16.

[29] Ibid.,

[30] Michael Amaladoss, Making Harmony, 43.

[31] Ibid.,17.

[32] Ibid., 18.

[33] Michael Amaladoss, Dialogue as Conflict Resolution, 17.

Obstacles to Dialogue


1. Introduction
2. Michael Amaladoss’ Background; A call to dialogue
4. Meaning, goals and Three Faces of Interreligious Dialogue
5. Forms of Interreligious Dialogue

6. Obstacles to Dialogue
Amaladoss realizes that in implementing Interreligious Dialogue in an Asian context is not such an easy thing, it is difficult, indeed. He, then, mentions that prejudice, secularism, fundamentalism, communalism and stereotypes can be major hindrances to involvement in inter-religious encounter or dialogue in the Asian context.
[28] Amaladoss highlights that Prejudice has its roots often in ignorance. He mentions the caste system in India as a good example of it. It seems that the caste system has come automatically from living in an exclusive society in their own world and in ignorance of the presence of other beliefs and other peoples.[29] The gap left by ignorance is filled by prejudice and it will be transmitted from generation to generation.

Secularism, on the other hand, is “an ideology which focuses on humanity and reason and ignores, if it does not deny, God and the transcendent, which are aspects of experience that religion believes in”[30]. One of the most common happens in secularist countries where religion loses its role and appears as a tendency to privatize religion. The emergence of globalization has carried tremendous impacts upon the life of Asian people. If not most, many of Asian people tend to wall themselves into “a new world”; a life of materialism and a life of consumerism. This “world” has successfully fortified them into the extreme of individualistic and secularist society.

Fundamentalism is a religious attitude understood as a narrow affirmation of the truth of one’s own beliefs. Fundamentalism tends to promote a state religion. This tendency is widespread throughout the world. In India , for instance, Hinduism dominates public life. Inter-religious dialogue has no space in the fundamentalist society.[31] In the fundamentalist world others religions tend to be regarded as of second class status, even the ‘enemy’.

Communalism, on the other hand, is a political attitude. Communalism believes that people who share the same religious beliefs also share the same economic and political interest[32]. The danger of this group is that it tends to regard other beliefs as enemies and the followers second class citizens. Tolerance or acceptance is far from praxis while nursing hatred and mistrusting becomes a menu of daily life.

Finally stereotyping is one of the obstacles to the Interreligious Dialogue according to Amaladoss. We tend to categorize others in terms of the group they belong to. The group itself is characterized as an out-group, which is opposed to an in-group (enemy syndrome) to which I myself belong and which gives me my social identity. The relationship between the groups is often conditioned by economic (material benefits) and political (power relations) circumstances. Such stereotyping can block communication and dialogue. When the stereotype is in place, Amaladoss presumes, concrete data about an individual are either ignored or seen as an exception.[33]

7. Theological Reflection and Conclusion
Bilbiography

Forms of Interreligious Dialogue


1. Introduction
2. Michael Amaladoss’ Background; A call to dialogue
4. Meaning, goals and Three Faces of Interreligious Dialogue

5. Forms of Interreligious Dialogue

In his discourse of Jesuit in Inter-Religious Dialogue in India, Michael Amaladoss highlights some forms of interreligious dialogue where the Jesuits involved themselves in social and liberative action with other religions. For the Jesuits involvement in Interreligious Dialogue is very much part of their mission which had already been started by the preceding Jesuits in 16th century. The documents of the church speak about four types of dialogue; they are dialogue of action, the dialogue of Life, the Dialogue of Intellectual Exchange, and Dialogue of Experience. Amaladoss, however, adds another type of dialogue that is dialogue as conflict reconciliation[18] in which he believes that this is relevant to the Asian context in general and the Indian context in particular where these types of dialogues have come to the ‘ground’.

He views the dialogue of action as collaboration, not merely with the people who have faith but also with the secular groups. He draws the example when the Tsunami struck the Indian coast, the Jesuits engaged in refurbishing the buildings in the Nagapattinam district, a place known as under the banner of secularism.[19] This form of dialogue is directed towards planning and carrying out projects or actions that will help the entire people, as mentioned earlier. Here the policy or aim of cooperation and respect is adopted to replace hostility and aggression in the ‘other’. By working together, the group enhances the development of their area. Joint projects/actions, such as setting up schools, clinics, water projects, can help to bring people together and also to uplift their human condition. Dialogue of action involves contract in daily life and common commitment to action.

Dialogue of life, in his point of view, is where people strive to live in an open and neighborly spirit, sharing their joys and sorrows, their human problems and preoccupations. In India , as he mentions, the Jesuits have had a strong presence and involvement in the field of education and there are many students and teachers from other religions.[20] In other words, they open the window to the presence of others in their institutions without any hesitation. There was a consensus that an integral education also included religious education. The Jesuits, however, educate them in their own faith (religion). In addition, prayers and passages from scriptures from other religions are also regularly used during the common prayers.

The Dialogue of Intellectual Exchange is understood as specialists seek to deepen their understanding of their respective religious heritages, and to an appreciation of each other's spiritual values. The aim of this dialogue is not to discover the weaknesses of each religion but the dialogue is much more; it involves mutual understanding and the greatest respect for each other.[21] In this stage, Jesuits in India built three centers that promote the study of different religions. It has shown the real results of these collaborations in promoting seminars and publications on intercultural philosophy, and also publish the Hindu-Christian Studies Bulletin by scholars both Hindus and Christians.

The dialogue of religious experience is viewed where persons, rooted in their own religious traditions, share their spiritual riches, for instance with regard to prayer and contemplation, faith and ways of searching for God or the Absolute. Praying together is one common expression that has been used in the dialogue of spiritual experience. Amaladoss acknowledges that praying together with other religions has been happening for many years in India . This notion was introduced by John Paul II when he invited the leaders of other religions to come to Assisi and pray for peace in October 1986.[22] According to Amaladoss the ability to pray together between Hindus and Christians is found easily when the attention is focused on God and not on any particular religious manifestation such as Jesus or Krishna .

Amaladoss, then, mentions another kind of dialogue; Dialogue as Conflict Resolution. The aim of introducing this, in Michael Amaladoss’ point of view is to promote inter-religious harmony and peace and build community where “inter-religious dialogue tensions and communal conflict” is happening.[23] The aim of this interreligious dialogue, according to Amaladoss, is precisely to build up a ‘public’ that is multi-religious. It is inevitable that arising conflicts indicate that there are massive tensions in the community due to discrimination, injustice and misunderstanding, particularly in the Asian context. The question should be raised now; how should interreligious dialogue as conflict resolution be done in the context of a community of people who believe in different religions? He highly recommends four activities that should be implemented in Interreligious Dialogue as conflict resolution.

The first and foremost element of interreligious dialogue as conflict resolution is the ‘Conscientization’.[24] Amaladoss strongly believes that conscientization is a center or source of transforming incorrect attitudes in human life. Creating our own prejudices and stereotypes can influence our perceptions or opinions or even attitudes to others. He suggests that these kinds of attitudes should be changed by creating a new experience of community through dialogue and common action for justice. Doing this, however, is not through performing great preaching or abstract arguments but rather simply involves in multi-religious groups disclosing their problems. It is significant to note that understanding, accepting and respecting others are prominent points to be considered. This means that the possibility of pluralism as part of community lives should be accepted. Accepting pluralism means the ability to accept differences on any levels.

The second aspect of interreligious dialogue as conflict resolution is through creating a Multi-Religious Public Space. He emphasizes that “one way of promoting a multi religious community is to facilitate the formation of voluntary groups based on a variety of cultural, and social interests like music and the arts, sports and other social activities”. [25] Amaladoss believes that as people start belonging to many groups, strong and devious group identities start breaking down. Involvement in multiple groups helps people to identify themselves in a positive way in terms of what brings the groups for common goals and not to identify the identity in a narrow way. [26] These groups, however, must not only be task-oriented but wisely create a space for symbolic celebration of different religions in relaxed way. Schools and colleges are good places to start these groups in various ways.

The third aspect of this activity is the ‘Collaboration in Action’. According to Amaladoss to act together, promoting the equality and justice in a non religious sphere is the most effective way of building multi-religious community. This collaborative network can be done in various ways, such as working together with the governmental and non governmental agencies with the purpose of promoting the development of all without any discrimination. This collaboration also can be manifested at the political level to achieve the neutrality of political institutions. Amaladoss, however, reminds us that these entire collaborative networks should be done in the geographical area with the intention of improving local facilities. Amaladoss draws the example of involvement which breaks down narrow identification when more than two hundred groups came together to move the courts, to demand action in Mumbai ( India ). He believes that common actions (good intentions) are the only way to defeat the basic principle of communalism.

Finally, Deepening the Relationship is one of the activities that have been suggested by Amaladoss in order to proclaim Interreligious Dialogue as conflict resolution. At this point Amaladoss tries to re-emphasize the idea from an outstanding figure in India back in the 19th century. He acclaims that “one of the tools that Gandhi used for promoting inter-religious harmony was inter-religious prayer and meetings”.[27] In these meetings, passages from the different of scriptures of the various religions were read and songs were sung before drawing the conclusion of promoting interreligious peace and harmony. Indeed, the common sharing of the scriptures, prayers and reflections in his view can lead to a deepening of understanding both of one’s own religions and of the others. The aim of this would be to enable the challenges of the shortcomings of religions involved in a constructive way.


6. Obstacles to Dialogue
7. Theological Reflection and Conclusion
Bilbiography

Meaning, Goals, and Three Faces of Interreligious Dialogue


1. Introduction
2. Michael Amaladoss’ Background; A call to dialogue

4. Meaning, Goals, and Three Faces of Interreligious Dialogue

4.1. Meaning

According to Amaladoss dialogue goes beyond communicative action, because what we are looking for is not merely a rational consensus, but the emergence of a community of love.[7] This is to say that Dialogue should be approached with humility, sincerity, honesty, openness to, and trust in the ‘other’. This is what makes Interreligious Dialogue different because he argues that it has religion “touches the deepest layers of persons and social aspects, speaks an absolutist language and those involved are ready to die in defense of their faith and commitment”.[8]

Amaladoss, then, broadens the meaning of interreligious dialogue by emphasizing that, by means of recognizing the action of God in other religions, Interreligious Dialogue in the Asian context must become a duty and necessity. It is not merely a method and an option. In this view other religions must not be seen as enemies to cope with but rather allies to collaborate with. In this sense inter-religious dialogue is an effort to integrate the idea of the promotion of the Kingdom of God .[9]

Based on this understanding Amaladoss, then, argues that interreligious dialogue is essential for mutual understanding and enrichment in the religious sphere.[10] This means that those who engage in dialogue should be open to one another and unveil what takes place in their culture, religion, society and listen intently to the ‘other’ and learn.

4.2. Goals

He, then, points out that the aims of dialogue are not merely promotion of mutual understanding and sharing of spiritual experiences. The focus of interreligious dialogue, then, must always emphasise the common search for truth, for experience of God and for theological understanding. These are necessary dimensions of interreligious dialogue just as we understand the emergence of religion is not for its own sake but for the life of humanity. The fundamental goal of interreligious, therefore, is for common prophetic action and commitment. In this view, each believer is invited to analyze the contemporary issues and their problems. By proposing and judging these problems each believer eventually will find the meaning.

4.3. The Three Faces of Interreligious Dialogue

Amaladoss, then, explains three faces of dialogue. They are dialogue and Liberation, dialogue and culture, and dialogue: an inter-religious encounter.[11] He believes that these aspects complement each other and manifest as proclamation.

4.3.1. Dialogue and Liberation

In promoting justice and liberation to the marginalized, distressed, crushed, and downtrodden and the needy people in a multi-religious society like Asia , Amaladoss asserts that inter-religious dialogue which goes beyond faith sharing and spiritual fellowship can enrich and lead to a holistic vision through complementarities of perspectives.[12]

This is to say that religion should display a prophetic power for liberation which believes that religion has the interior power to change the peoples’ hearts. In doing so, Amaladoss suggests that life and liberation must embrace the transcendent existence and keep up the collaboration in both areas. Interreligious Dialogue, however, he reminds us “can not be confined to the religious sphere only but must embrace all the dimensions of life: economic, socio political, cultural and religious.”[13] In this stage, Amaladoss alleges that Interreligious Dialogue comes to an urgency and relevance level.

4.3.2. Dialogue and Cultures

It is believed that culture relates to the way people live whereas, religion deals with the ultimate experiences and questions. “Religion has to be rooted in a culture in order to be able to relate to a particular human group and influence their lives and behavior”.[14] The relation between religion and culture, however, is very complex. This relationship is shown when religion stipulates various meanings and inspirations about religious symbols and is celebrated in certain rituals. However, “how do we envisage or consider a culture that is actually shared by persons who are committed to various religions”?[15] Amaladoss emphasizes that the possibility is there to cope with this issue by showing a respectful attitude to the other religions and striving together with them to provide a common religious dimension to their common culture.

4.3.3. Dialogue: as an Interreligious Encounter

Amaladoss remarks that in doing interreligious dialogue, we are not merely informed about the great things that God has done through others’ lives and histories but more importantly are called to be mindful of the limitations that other people have. In other words, “if God has manifested Himself in other religious traditions, however inadequately, the manifestation is relevant to us; it is also a word for us”.[16] Amaladoss quotes the Asian bishops’ prayer in “For the People of Asia ”,

Sustained and reflective dialogue with them in prayer (as shall be found possible, helpful and wise in different situations) will reveal to us what the Holy Spirit has taught others to express in a marvelous variety of ways. These are different perhaps from our own, but through them we too may hear His voice, calling us to lift our hearts to the Father[17].


5. Forms of Interreligious Dialogue
6. Obstacles to Dialogue
7. Theological Reflection and Conclusion
Bilbiography

Michael Amaladoss’ Background; A call to dialogue

1. Introduction

2. Michael Amaladoss' Background; A call to dialogue
Michael Amaladoss was born in 1936 in Tamil Nadu India . He is a member of the Society of Jesus. He is a Professor of Systematic Theology at Vidyajyoti College of Theology in Delhi , and the Director of the Institute for Dialogue with Cultures and Religions, Chennai , India . He is also a well known international speaker and writer, and has written extensively on issues of mission and liberation Theology. More than 20 books and over 300 articles have been written by him in various languages (German, English and Hindi). Most of these books and articles are connecting with the Asian context. His present job is a lecturer at the East Asian Pastoral Institute (EAPI).

There are three explicit books in which he talks about the Interreligious Dialogue. They are Making All Things New; Dialogue, Pluralism and Evangelization in Asia ; Walking Together: the Practice of Inter-Religious Dialogue; and Making Harmony, Living in a Pluralist World. In his book,’ Walking Together’, he explores the authentic calling of Christianity to dialogue. To be a Christian means to be ready to handle this responsibility. He, therefore, strongly encourages the theologians in Asia to comprehend this essential calling by integrating this positive attitude to other religions in the context of the Reign to which God is leading all peoples.[5] This is simply to say that in a multi-cultural and pluralistic society like Asia , all people are invited and challenged to move out of their cultures and ideologies to welcome and embrace the ‘other’.

Interreligious Dialogue for Amaladoss, therefore, is the “way” to build up “a long bridge” on which we can “walk” to meet (relate) with other people who have different religions and cultures from us. The possibility of building the bridge also can break down the ‘wall of individualism’, which can be a great hindrance for implementing Interreligious Dialogue. In doing this, it will be discovered what Michael Amaladoss called a ‘community of communities’ because there is no more a conglomeration of individuals, but it is a variety of ethnic, cultural and religious groups. In this sense, the goal of Interreligious Dialogue is precisely to build up a public entity that is multi-religious.[6]

4. Meaning, goals and Three Faces of Interreligious Dialogue
4.1. Meaning
4.2. Goals
4.3. Three Faces of Interreligious Dialogue
4.3.1. Dialogue and Liberation
4.3.2. Dialogue and Cultures
4.3.3. Dialogue: as an Interreligious Encounter
5. Forms of Interreligious Dialogue
6. Obstacles to Dialogue
7. Theological Reflection and Conclusion
Bilbiography